SYED MD SAIFULLAH, my Uncle, served Govt. Of India as an IAAS officer with many credits. He served under Foreign Minister Atal Vihari Vajpayee Ji.
SEARCH THIS BLOG
Sunday, August 18, 2024
SYED MD SAIFULLAH, My Uncle, Assamese Kuhiyarboriya Syed Dawon
Monday, February 12, 2024
COMPARISION AMONG ASP, MBBR, SBR AND MBR
COMPARISION AMONG ASP,
MBBR, SBR AND MBR
Technology |
ASP |
MBBR |
SBR |
MBR |
Aeration
Unit |
Needs
a Big Aeration Tank with surface aerators or diffused aeration. |
Floating
media is used providing a surface for microbial growth |
Operates
in batch where waste water is added to the reactor, treated and discharges. |
Normal
biological treatment like MBBR |
Settling
Unit |
Uses
a Common circular Settling Tank |
A
tube settler is used for high sludge removal rate. |
NIL |
Membrane
filtration process in place of Settler. |
Efficiency |
Average
Efficiency |
High
Treatment efficiency. Robust against fluctuation flow
and load |
Flexibility
in Treatment. High Nutrient removal |
Superior
effluent quality due to membrane barrier. |
Area |
Largest
Area |
Most
compact system |
Requires
less area than ASP |
50%
less area then SBR |
Uses |
Used
in Municipal waste water treatment
plant |
Used
in Decentralized waste water treatment plant and Industries. |
Suitable
for smaller STP. It has some constraints in Municipal waste water treatment plant |
Used
in Decentralized waste water treatment plant and Industries, especially when
plant is to be designed for zero discharge. |
Cost |
Medium
Cost EASY
TO MAINTAIN |
Lowest
capital and maintenance cost, EASY TO MAINTAIN |
High
maintenance cost |
High
Energy Load, Maintenance cost 20% lower than SBR |